Comic Blind Comparison Review

wanshuiyin/comic-blind-comparison-review

Phase-1 comic-author step (post-final eval) — a DOUBLE-BLIND A/B of two FINAL whole comics: our cross-model-audited progressive render (the comic-author + comic-director output) vs a naive single-shot baseline. A single sealed coin-flip hides which is which; two cross-model reviewers (Codex + Gemini) score both on a fixed rubric reading only a SHARED blind spec (intent + ART_BIBLE); only AFTER both reviews land do we unseal, re-label, and write a Chinese comparison.md + the A/B verdict nodes. editability/traceability is the structural wedge that can win even when the baseline looks prettier. Use when the user says "和 baseline 比", "blind comparison", "A/B 评测", "对比 baseline", "盲评", "whole-comic vs one-shot", or a finished comic needs a baseline-relative honest verdict. NOT an authoring skill and NOT the per-panel panel_gate / assembly_gate — those run DURING production; this runs AFTER, on two complete works.