Issue Gate

Issue Gate

Overview

Run issue preflight before any new implementation task. Keep GitHub Issues as the source of truth and return one decision: CREATE, CLAIM, ABORT_IN_PROGRESS, or ABORT_UNCERTAIN.

Workflow

• Prepare inputs:
• repository (owner/repo)
• actor login
• task title
• task body file path
• Fetch open issues using gh:

gh api --paginate "/repos/owner/repo/issues?state=open&per_page=100" | jq -s '
  add
  | [ .[]
      | select(.pull_request | not)
      | {
          number: .number,
          title: .title,
          body: (.body // ""),
          url: .html_url,
          labels: [ .labels[]?.name ],
          assignees: [ .assignees[]?.login ]
        }
    ]'

• Run qualitative LLM matching using task + open issues and produce ISSUE_GATE_MATCH_JSON.
• Derive and emit one decision with this contract:

{
  "decision": "CREATE|CLAIM|ABORT_IN_PROGRESS|ABORT_UNCERTAIN",
  "matched_issue_number": 123,
  "reason": "string",
  "human_action": "string"
}

• Apply gate behavior:
• CREATE: create issue and continue task against the created issue.
• CLAIM: ensure actor assignment and labels, then continue task against the claimed issue. If the issue is already assigned to ACTOR, skip re-assigning.
• ABORT_IN_PROGRESS: stop task and hand off only when the matched issue is in progress and not assigned to the current actor.
• ABORT_UNCERTAIN: stop task and request human triage.
• When creating the PR for the task, reference the issue in the PR description using a closing keyword (for example: Closes #$ISSUE).

LLM Matching Input (required)

Provide qualitative matching from the runtime LLM with ISSUE_GATE_MATCH_JSON:

{
  "classification": "clear|ambiguous|none",
  "matched_issue_number": 123,
  "reason": "short explanation"
}

Rules:

• ISSUE_GATE_MATCH_JSON is required.
• Missing or malformed ISSUE_GATE_MATCH_JSON returns ABORT_UNCERTAIN.
• classification=clear requires a positive integer matched_issue_number.

Decision Mapping

• classification=ambiguous -> ABORT_UNCERTAIN.
• classification=none -> CREATE.
• classification=clear:
• If matched issue is in progress and assigned to someone other than ACTOR -> ABORT_IN_PROGRESS.
• If matched issue is in progress and assigned to ACTOR -> CLAIM.
• If matched issue is not started -> CLAIM.

In-progress signal:

• Issue has label status:in-progress, or
• Issue has one or more assignees.

Ownership rule:

• If any assignee login equals ACTOR, treat issue as owned by current actor and continue (CLAIM).
• If issue is in progress and no assignee matches ACTOR, abort (ABORT_IN_PROGRESS).

GH Commands

• Create issue:
• gh api -X POST "/repos/$REPO/issues" -f "title=$TASK_TITLE" -F "body=@$TASK_BODY_FILE"
• Claim issue:
• gh api "/repos/$REPO/issues/$ISSUE" --jq '.assignees[]?.login' | grep -Fxq "$ACTOR" || gh api -X POST "/repos/$REPO/issues/$ISSUE/assignees" -f "assignees[]=$ACTOR"
• gh api -X POST "/repos/$REPO/issues/$ISSUE/labels" -f "labels[]=status:in-progress" || true
• gh api -X DELETE "/repos/$REPO/issues/$ISSUE/labels/status:todo" >/dev/null 2>&1 || true

References

• Matching rubric: references/match-rubric.md
• Manual Claude usage: references/claude-usage.md