mcpbeat Sign in

Commentary Review MCP Server

by commentary Your server? Claim it
answering

Commentary Review is answering right now. Last checked 5 min ago.

Human-owned review for agent plans, rendered documents, Forms, research, and live previews.

Uptime history 18 days of history
18 days agonow
100.0%
Uptime 24h
93 of 93 checks
Tools
hidden behind auth
517 ms
Response time
average over 24h
OAuth sign-in
Access
streamable-http

Nothing serious here today

Today is the operative word: we check Commentary Review every 15 minutes and re-read its code on every release. Watch it and you find out the day that stops being true.

Three servers free · no card

Connect this server

Endpoint below is the one we actually reach during checks — not the one copied from a README. Last verified 5 min ago.

run in your terminal
claude mcp add review --transport http https://commentary.dev/mcp
~/Library/Application Support/Claude/claude_desktop_config.json
{
  "mcpServers": {
    "review": {
      "url": "https://commentary.dev/mcp"
    }
  }
}
~/.codex/config.toml
[mcp_servers.review]
url = "https://commentary.dev/mcp"
.cursor/mcp.json
{
  "mcpServers": {
    "review": {
      "url": "https://commentary.dev/mcp"
    }
  }
}
.vscode/mcp.json
{
  "mcpServers": {
    "review": {
      "url": "https://commentary.dev/mcp"
    }
  }
}

This endpoint answered with an authorization challenge — the server is running, but you need an API key or OAuth to use it.

Endpoints

URLTransportStateLatencyChecked
https://commentary.dev/mcp streamable-http needs key 495 ms 5 min ago

Alternatives to Commentary Review

same job, measured the same way
MCP Documentation Server
by andrea9293

Local-first document management and semantic search for AI coding agents

87 installs/wk local only
MagicTeX
by zoelinuts

LaTeX editor for AI agents: live PDF preview, PDF comments that drive edits, git history

52 installs/wk local only
boxpdf-html
by earonesty

Render HTML to PDF (html_to_pdf) plus boxpdf library docs and templates, for AI agents.

77 installs/wk local only
Carve
by markup-carve

Parse, lint, format, render, and migrate Carve documents through MCP.

446 installs/wk local only
Doc Bridge
by agentskit-io

Resolve documentation ownership, edit roots, checks, and human handoffs before an agent edits code.

12 859 installs/wk local only
Intenttext MCP
by intenttext

Parse, validate, query, and render IntentText (.it) documents for AI agents

23 installs/wk local only
A
Melt Peer Review
by meltstudio

Send AI-made document changes for human review, then read the decisions back.

answering
FreeSign — Free e-signature
by free-sign

Free e-signature for humans and AI agents — zero-document PDF signing from hashes only.

5 tools answering

Commentary Review — questions

Answers built from our own checks of this server.

Why is there no tool list for Commentary Review?
The server answered our handshake with an authorization challenge, so it is running — but it will not describe its tools to an anonymous client. To see them you need to connect with your own credentials. We record it as alive, not as broken: 100.0% of checks in the last 24 hours got a reply.
Is Commentary Review working right now?
We send a real MCP handshake every 15 minutes. Over the last 24 hours 93 of 93 checks got a reply (100.0%), average response time 517 ms. The bar chart above shows every period we have measured.
How do I connect Commentary Review?
Copy the ready config from this page — we generate it for Claude Code, Claude Desktop, Codex, Cursor and VS Code, each with the file path that client actually reads. It is a remote server, so there is nothing to install — the client connects to the address. You sign in through your browser once and the client keeps the session: no key to copy, and it refuses anonymous clients.
How do you sign in to Commentary Review?
No API key is involved. Commentary Review answers our knock with an OAuth challenge, so you authorise it once in your browser and the client keeps the session. That is also why we see no tool list: it will not describe itself to an anonymous client, and that is the server working as intended, not a fault.
How fast is Commentary Review?
It answers our handshake in 517 ms on average, which is faster than 31% of all working MCP servers we measure. The comparison comes from our own checks across the whole registry, every 15 minutes.