Dedup Openai

De-duplicate Generated Classes Against openai-java

Use this skill after the dup-classes skill has identified actionable duplicates. This skill suppresses the generated classes and bridges to the openai-java equivalents.

Preconditions

• A tsp-location.yaml must exist in the current directory.
• TypeSpec must be synced (tsp-client sync) so TempTypeSpecFiles/ exists.
• The openai-java dependency must be in the project's pom.xml.
• You must know which classes to suppress (use dup-classes skill first).

Key concepts

What can be suppressed

Only standalone models that don't participate in a discriminator hierarchy. A model is standalone if:

• It does NOT extend Tool, TextResponseFormatConfiguration, or another base class with a fromJson discriminator
• It is NOT a subtype dispatched by a parent's fromJson method

What cannot be suppressed

Structural equivalents — classes that extend a base type in a discriminator hierarchy (e.g., FunctionTool extends Tool). The SDK's polymorphic serialization requires these. They produce identical JSON but are not actionable. Do NOT attempt to suppress them.

Two suppression mechanisms

| Mechanism | When to use | Effect |

|-----------|-------------|--------|

| @@alternateType(OpenAI.X, { identity: "com.openai.models.X" }, "java") | The model is referenced as a field type or union member in other models | Codegen replaces the type with the openai-java class. The generated class is NOT emitted at all. |

| @@access(OpenAI.X, Access.internal, "java") | The model is NOT referenced by any public model | Codegen moves the class to implementation.models. |

Prefer @@alternateType — it fully prevents emission and is the cleanest approach. Use @@access(internal) only as a supplement when a model isn't reachable through the type graph but is still emitted.

Why @@access(internal) alone may not work

If a model is referenced by a union or property in a public model, @@access(internal) will NOT move it. The codegen keeps it public because removing it would break the type graph. Example: ComparisonFilter is a member of the Filters union used by FileSearchTool.filters — @@access(internal) has no effect, but @@alternateType prevents emission entirely.

Steps

1. Edit the TypeSpec client file

Locate the client.tsp (or client.java.tsp) in TempTypeSpecFiles/sdk-*/:

find TempTypeSpecFiles -name "client*.tsp" -path "*/sdk-*"

Add @@alternateType directives for each actionable duplicate:

// De-dup: map to openai-java equivalents
@@alternateType(OpenAI.ComparisonFilter, { identity: "com.openai.models.ComparisonFilter" }, "java");
@@alternateType(OpenAI.Reasoning, { identity: "com.openai.models.Reasoning" }, "java");

Finding the correct model name: The TypeSpec models are in the OpenAI namespace. Search the openai-typespec package:

grep -rn "^model <ClassName>" TempTypeSpecFiles/node_modules/@azure-tools/openai-typespec/src/ --include="*.tsp"

2. Regenerate and verify

tsp-client generate

After generation, verify the suppressed classes are gone:

# Should NOT exist:
ls src/main/java/com/azure/ai/agents/models/<SuppressedClass>.java
# Should NOT exist in implementation either (with @@alternateType):
ls src/main/java/com/azure/ai/agents/implementation/models/<SuppressedClass>.java

3. Fix serialization in parent models

When a model's property type changes from a generated JsonSerializable class to an openai-java class, the toJson/fromJson methods in parent models will break because the openai-java type doesn't implement JsonSerializable.

Pattern for toJson — use OpenAIJsonHelper.toBinaryData():

// Before (generated, won't compile):
jsonWriter.writeJsonField("reasoning", this.reasoning);

// After:
if (this.reasoning != null) {
    jsonWriter.writeFieldName("reasoning");
    OpenAIJsonHelper.toBinaryData(this.reasoning).writeTo(jsonWriter);
}

Pattern for fromJson — read as BinaryData, convert with OpenAIJsonHelper.fromBinaryData():

// Before (generated, won't compile):
reasoning = Reasoning.fromJson(reader);

// After:
BinaryData reasoningData
    = reader.getNullable(nonNullReader -> BinaryData.fromObject(nonNullReader.readUntyped()));
reasoning = OpenAIJsonHelper.fromBinaryData(reasoningData, com.openai.models.Reasoning.class);

Pattern for getter/setter — use the openai-java type directly, with javadoc above and marker comment inside the body:

// Field stores the openai-java type directly (no BinaryData indirection)
private com.openai.models.Reasoning reasoning; // AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup

/**
 * Gets the reasoning configuration.
 * @return the reasoning, or null if not set.
 */
public com.openai.models.Reasoning getReasoning() {
    // AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup
    return this.reasoning;
}

/**
 * Sets the reasoning configuration.
 * @param reasoning the reasoning to set.
 * @return this object.
 */
public PromptAgentDefinition setReasoning(com.openai.models.Reasoning reasoning) {
    // AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup
    this.reasoning = reasoning;
    return this;
}

Remove @Generated from any method you modify so the codegen preserves your changes on re-generation. See Codegen survival rules for comment/javadoc placement.

4. Add typed convenience setters (for BinaryData fields)

When a property is already BinaryData (e.g., because it's a union type), add distinctly named setter methods for the openai-java types. Do NOT overload setX with different parameter types — this causes null-ambiguity. Use descriptive names instead:

/**
 * Sets the filters using an openai-java ComparisonFilter.
 * @param filter the filter to apply, or null to clear.
 * @return this object.
 */
public FileSearchTool setComparisonFilter(com.openai.models.ComparisonFilter filter) {
    // AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup
    this.filters = OpenAIJsonHelper.toBinaryData(filter);
    return this;
}

/**
 * Sets the filters using an openai-java CompoundFilter.
 * @param filter the filter to apply, or null to clear.
 * @return this object.
 */
public FileSearchTool setCompoundFilter(com.openai.models.CompoundFilter filter) {
    // AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup
    this.filters = OpenAIJsonHelper.toBinaryData(filter);
    return this;
}

5. Add OpenAIJsonHelper methods if needed

The OpenAIJsonHelper class in com.azure.ai.agents.implementation may need two bridge methods:

// Serialize openai-java object → BinaryData (writes as JSON object, not quoted string)
public static BinaryData toBinaryData(Object openAIObject)

// Deserialize BinaryData → openai-java type
public static <T> T fromBinaryData(BinaryData data, Class<T> type)

These use the openai-java ObjectMappers.jsonMapper() (which handles Kotlin internals correctly). Do NOT use BinaryData.fromObject() or BinaryData.toObject() with openai-java types — the default Jackson ObjectMapper cannot serialize Kotlin SynchronizedLazyImpl fields.

6. Write serialization tests

Write round-trip tests verifying the JSON shape is preserved. Test pattern:

@Test
public void testRoundTrip() throws IOException {
    // Build with openai-java type
    Reasoning reasoning = Reasoning.builder().effort(ReasoningEffort.HIGH).build();
    PromptAgentDefinition original = new PromptAgentDefinition("gpt-4o").setReasoning(reasoning);

    // Serialize
    String json = serialize(original);
    assertTrue(json.contains("\"effort\":\"high\""));

    // Deserialize
    PromptAgentDefinition deserialized = deserialize(json);
    assertEquals(ReasoningEffort.HIGH, deserialized.getReasoning().effort().get());

    // Re-serialize and compare
    assertEquals(json, serialize(deserialized));
}

Cover: all enum values, null/absent fields, combined with other fields, polymorphic deserialization via parent fromJson.

7. Apply changes to the spec repo

If a local checkout of Azure/azure-rest-api-specs is available, apply the same client.tsp edits there. Derive the path from tsp-location.yaml:

<spec_repo>/<directory>/client.tsp

Codegen survival rules

The TypeSpec Java codegen (tsp-client update / tsp-client generate) will re-generate files on every run. Methods without @Generated are preserved (body intact), but everything above the method signature (javadoc, comments) is regenerated. Follow these rules so your manual edits survive:

• Remove @Generated from any method you modify. The codegen will not overwrite the method body.
• Place marker comments inside the method body, not above the signature. The codegen rewrites the javadoc block above the signature but does not touch the body.
• Place javadoc above the method normally. Since the method lacks @Generated, the codegen preserves the javadoc you wrote.
• For field declarations, place marker comments on the same line (trailing), not on the line above. The codegen regenerates the comment block above the field.

// ✅ SURVIVES codegen: javadoc above, marker inside body
/**
 * Gets the reasoning configuration.
 * @return the reasoning, or null if not set.
 */
public com.openai.models.Reasoning getReasoning() {
    // AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup  ← inside body, survives
    return this.reasoning;
}

// ❌ WIPED by codegen: marker above signature
// AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup  ← above signature, gets wiped
public com.openai.models.Reasoning getReasoning() {
    return this.reasoning;
}

// ✅ SURVIVES codegen: field marker on same line
private com.openai.models.Reasoning reasoning; // AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup

// ❌ WIPED by codegen: field marker on line above
// AI Tooling: openai-java de-dup
private com.openai.models.Reasoning reasoning;

Common pitfalls

| Problem | Cause | Fix |

|---------|-------|-----|

| Class stays public despite @@access(internal) | Referenced by a union or property in a public model | Use @@alternateType instead |

| BinaryData.fromObject(openAIObj) throws SynchronizedLazyImpl error | Default Jackson can't serialize Kotlin internals | Use OpenAIJsonHelper.toBinaryData() which uses ObjectMappers.jsonMapper() |

| BinaryData.fromString(json).writeTo(writer) writes quoted string | fromString creates text content, not JSON | Use BinaryData.fromObject(reader.readUntyped()) to store as a JSON object |

| Getter/setter bridge through BinaryData on every call | Unnecessary indirection | Store the openai-java type directly in the field; bridge only in toJson/fromJson |

| Tried to suppress a Tool subclass | Structural equivalent, not an actionable duplicate | Don't suppress — it's needed for polymorphic deserialization |

| Javadoc/comments above method wiped after codegen | Codegen rewrites everything above non-@Generated method signatures | Place marker comments inside the method body; javadoc survives if @Generated is removed (see Codegen survival rules) |

| Overloaded setters cause null ambiguity | setFilters(null) matches BinaryData, ComparisonFilter, and CompoundFilter | Use distinct method names: setComparisonFilter(), setCompoundFilter() |